With the recent pressure to reduce or scale back diversity programs, we have some news - our data says employees like their company’s diversity, equity and inclusion (DE&I) efforts. While our response may be controversial, the Q4 2024 Employee Experience & Engagement Survey by Engage2Excel sheds light on how U.S. employees perceive their employers’ DE&I initiatives. It provides valuable insights into workplace diversity and what employees want as organizations reevaluate their diversity programs.
High Favorability Towards Diversity Initiatives
One of the most striking findings from the survey is that a significant majority (71.3%) of employees favor their employers' efforts to create inclusive work environments. This high favorability is consistent across various diversity-related items in the survey, indicating that employees appreciate initiatives that promote diversity and inclusion. These efforts are essential for fostering a workplace where everyone can thrive, develop their talents and contribute to the organization's success.
Backlash and Confusion
Despite the positive reception in the U.S., there is a growing backlash against diversity programs due to political pressures and misconceptions. Some view these initiatives as "woke" or discriminatory, and recent legal rulings, such as the Supreme Court decision against affirmative action, have further complicated the landscape. This backlash highlights the need for organizations to communicate the goals and benefits of their DE&I programs to mitigate resistance and confusion.
Distinguishing DE&I from Affirmative Action
In today's polarized political environment, efforts to promote diversity, equity and inclusion are often mistakenly associated with affirmative action programs. While affirmative action involves proactive measures to address historical underrepresentation, DE&I represents a broader concept focused on creating an inclusive environment for everyone. Employers must educate their workforce on the differences between these two approaches to ensure a clear understanding of their DE&I initiatives.
Historical Trends
The Employee Experience & Engagement Survey has tracked employee perceptions of workplace diversity since 2016. Over the years, more than two-thirds of workers have consistently favored their employers' diversity initiatives. Although the favorability scores have shown some fluctuations, they have generally remained high, reflecting a sustained appreciation for DE&I efforts. This historical data underscores the importance of maintaining and enhancing diversity programs to meet employees' expectations and foster a positive workplace culture.
Uniform Favorability Across Racial/Ethnic Groups
The survey reveals uniform favorability towards diversity initiatives across racial and ethnic groups. White/Caucasian and African American respondents showed nearly identical favorability scores. In contrast, Latin American/Hispanic and Asian/Pacific Islander respondents had slightly lower scores, indicating areas for improvement. This uniform support suggests that DE&I efforts are broadly appreciated but also highlights the need for targeted strategies to address specific concerns within different demographic groups.
Commitment to Diversity and Implications for Employers
Employees perceive their organizations as committed to diversity, with high scores for leadership commitment and the ease with which people from diverse backgrounds can fit in and excel. This perception is crucial for building employee trust and engagement, as it demonstrates that their employers are genuinely invested in creating a supportive and inclusive workplace. In light of these findings, employers should consider employees' views when contemplating changes to diversity programs. The positive reception of DE&I these initiatives suggest that scaling back these programs could negatively impact employee engagement and satisfaction.
Clear communication about the differences between DE&I and affirmative action is essential to address misconceptions and resistance. By educating their workforce on the broader goals of DE&I, employers can create a more supportive environment where everyone feels valued and empowered to succeed.
To continue reading the research brief, click the button below.
